Makeup Wars: Best Black Eyeliners

This week our bloggers are talking about their favorite black eyeliners. There are a million-jillion black eyeliners available, but these five are what I have been using for the past few months. Make sure to click on the icons at the end of this post to see what the rest of our bloggers chose!
Ultra-Definition-Eye-Lining-Stylus-315x315Eddie Funkhouser Ultra Definition Eye Lining Stylus ($10.99) – this tapered brush gives you excellent control and creates an ultra thin line. You won’t regret this purchase! Read my full review here. 
1404600016_s1345800-main-heroToo Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner ($18)this matte black liner is  creamy, long-wearing, glides on and lasts for eight hours of budge-proof, smudge-proof wear. There is smudger too! 1404599826_s1505213-main-heroMarc Jacobs Magic Marc’er Precision Pen Waterproof Eyeliner ($30) –  this design was inspired by the classic calligraphy pen. It works beautifully for drawing fine and winged lines. See my full review here. 1404599633_s1325448-main-heroMake Up For Ever Aqua Liner ($23)#14, Diamond Multicolor Black liquid liner has a black base with multicolor sparkles. This is so pretty and not at all over the top! There are 18 gorgeous shades! 1404599364_s1219518-main-heroUrban Decay 24/7 Glide On Eye Pencil ($20) – Oil Slick is a fabulous black with silver glitter that adds that extra oomph to eyes! It lasts forever and does NOT budge.
What are your fav black eyeliners?

From our partners


  1. great group of products!!! i like a lot of those!

  2. I’m completely obsessed with Urban decay liners!

  3. I need to try the Eddie Funkhouser!

  4. I totally forgot that Too Faced has an amazing eyeliner. I used to swear by it years ago and somehow I’ve forgotten all about it. That baby seriously doesn’t budge.

  5. Nice choices!!! I do love Tarte, but for some reason it falls out on me. I have such a hard time with great liners. I always forget about Eddie because he’s not available here. I love the liners by him I do have, but I’m always forgetting about it!

  6. The MUFE Aqua Liner sounds amazing!

  7. UD Zero & Black Velvet are my go-to liners, but maybe I should try Oil Slick for a little bling!

  8. I need to try the eddie funkhouser liner!

  9. I don’t know if I can resist that Marc Jacobs pen, but I’m going to try!

  10. I would love to try that Make Up For Ever liner!

  11. OH I want to try that Marc Jacobs!!

  12. Great selection of products. I want to try the Marc Jacobs one 😉

  13. I need to try that EF one!!

  14. I should try that Eddie Funkhouser eyeliner, it’s so inexpensive compared to the rest!

  15. I couldn’t find my MUFE liquid to include in my list. I’m glad to see that someone else loves Eddie Funkhouser as much as I do.

  16. I love Oil Slick – it’s gorgeous!

  17. I definitely want to try the one from Eddie Funkhouser!

  18. Loving so many of your choices!

  19. Nice roundup! I still haven’t tried anything from MJ, but maybe eventually I will splurge 🙂

  20. I’m happy you included Eddie Funkhouser, I like that liner too!

  21. I definitely agree with MUFE Aqua Liner. They are amazing!

  22. Love the MUFE liner!

  23. I am convinced more than ever than I need to try Eddie Funkhouser cosmetics!!! Thanks for this list, great picks!!!

  24. I haven’t tried any of the Eddie Funkhouser stuff yet. That liner sounds great.

  25. Looks like everyone is loving the Urban Decay!

  26. The UD tops my list too! But I forgot all about the MUFE Aqua Eyes – I don’t have it in black, but clearly I need it.

  27. love your picks, but I really love your image! so cute!

  28. I hope it’s not tacky to honk my own horn… HONK but if you are a Liquid Liner fanatic you will not be disappointed! Or if you have never tried a liquid liner because you are afraid to make a mess… I created my Ultra Definition Eye Lining Stylus for all of you! Give it a try, I know you will LOVE it. My goal and brand promise is to create high-performance products that do not sport the high price tag. Many consider my line to be mass because it doesn’t cost an arm and a leg. I don’t mind… I know who I am. 🙂

  29. Betzy Carmona says

    I would love to try the Marc Jacobs

  30. Love it. Urban Decay Liners have been a fav of mine for years